
AI helps you finish a return faster. You still have to verify the information, make decisions based on the client’s circumstances, and stand behind the work. Then the client asks a fair question: “If it took you less time, why am I paying the same?”
In this episode of The Growth Minded Accountant, Lee Reams II and Rebekah Barton take that question head-on. Rebekah makes the case that clients should see some benefit when work becomes more efficient. Lee asks what the client is paying for when a complex return calls for years of experience and careful review. For a firm that bills by the hour, there’s another question: What happens to revenue when the same work consistently takes less time?
The conversation brings back Sarah, the fictional firm owner from The $500,000 Trap. A longtime client, Michael, calls to say he’s thinking about selling a rental property. Sarah could spend the afternoon pulling records and answering questions under the annual tax prep fee. Instead, Lee and Rebekah walk through how she could offer a clearly scoped $750 planning review, explain what Michael would receive, and get his approval before she starts.
When AI takes time out of an engagement, look at what actually changed. If the firm can provide a faster turnaround or a simpler service, that may be a real benefit to the client. If the engagement still calls for complex analysis, careful review, or a consequential decision, explain that work in terms the client can understand.
The same thinking applies when a client asks for help beyond the annual return. Michael wants to make a decision before he sells. Sarah can explain what she’ll review, what she’ll deliver, and what it will cost while he still has time to act. That’s a clearer conversation than trying to explain an extra charge after the work is done.
Use ClientHub to keep client conversations and documents together. When a question calls for a separate planning engagement, send a proposal that spells out the work, get the engagement letter signed, and collect a deposit when appropriate.
Explore the CountingWorks PRO platform.
Acknowledge that AI can save time and explain where the client benefits. That might mean fewer requests for the same information, faster delivery, or more time to discuss a decision. Then explain what the fee covers, including the review and analysis that apply to their engagement.
If a return goes from three hours to one, figure out where the two hours went. Organizing documents and entering data may get faster while reviewing unusual items and resolving discrepancies still take professional time. Keep tracking delivery costs even when you quote a fixed fee. You need that information to know whether the engagement is profitable.
Clients typically see the finished return. They may never see the issue you caught, the inconsistency you resolved, or the option you evaluated before signing off. At renewal, explain the work in concrete terms. “We review changes in your business and flag decisions that may affect your tax position” tells a client more than “professional review included.”
When Michael asks about selling his rental, Sarah recognizes that an informed answer calls for reviewing his records and assumptions. The question gives her a reason to recommend a planning review. AI can help flag similar moments in client messages, intake forms, or meeting notes so the firm can decide which ones warrant follow-up.
In the episode’s example, Sarah proposes a preliminary review for $750. Michael would receive a written summary of key tax considerations and next steps, plus a meeting to discuss the findings. The proposal spells out the limits of the review so both sides understand when more detailed work would require another conversation.
A short planning engagement may call for payment upfront. A larger project may work better with a deposit or milestone payments. Agree on the scope, fee, and due dates before anyone starts. If the work expands, explain the change and get approval before doing it.
Choose a recurring client need your team can serve well. A preliminary rental-sale review or a focused retirement planning consultation can be enough to start. Define the deliverable, estimate your cost, set the fee, and offer it to a few clients who have a reason to act.
We know that everyone digests information differently. That’s why we’re now sharing the full transcript of each episode of The Growth Minded Accountant right here on the CountingWorks PRO blog. Whether you’re short on time, like to scan and highlight, or simply prefer reading over listening, you can catch up on every conversation at your own pace.
Each week, we cover topics that matter most to tax and accounting professionals—from AI and automation to marketing strategies, firm growth, and client relationships. Scroll down to read the full episode, or subscribe to the podcast to listen on the go.
Q. Should accounting firms charge less when they use AI?
It depends on the service and how it was priced. If the client pays by the hour and the work takes fewer billable hours, their bill may fall. For a fixed-fee engagement, review the scope, delivery cost, turnaround, and professional review involved before deciding whether to change the fee.
Q. Does AI make hourly billing obsolete for tax and accounting firms?
Hourly billing can still fit work that’s difficult to scope in advance. For repeatable work with clear deliverables, a fixed fee can give clients more certainty and help the firm benefit from improvements in how it delivers the service.
Q. What is judgment-based pricing?
In the episode, Lee uses the term to describe pricing that accounts for complexity, professional judgment, and responsibility alongside the time it takes to deliver the work. It’s a way to evaluate a fee across different kinds of engagements.
Q. How do I explain my fee when a client says AI did the work?
Start by acknowledging where AI helped. Then describe what your team reviewed, what decisions required professional input, and what the client receives. If the client expected a different service or fee, revisit the scope together.
Q. When should a client question become a separate advisory engagement?
Consider a separate engagement when answering requires substantial research, analysis, or a deliverable beyond what the client already agreed to. A rental property sale is one example. Before digging into the records, explain the proposed review and let the client decide whether to proceed.
Q. Can AI help a firm find advisory opportunities in its existing client base?
AI can flag mentions of events such as a property sale, an upcoming retirement, or a change in business ownership. A professional still needs to read the context, confirm the need, and decide whether outreach or a proposal would help the client.
Q. Should firms collect the entire advisory fee upfront?
Full payment, a deposit, and milestone payments can each make sense depending on the engagement and the firm’s policies. Whatever the arrangement, state the amount and timing in the proposal so the client knows what to expect before work begins.
Listen to other podcast episodes or read other related blog articles with relevant information and insights.